One of my post-paleo "treats" when I'm a little burned out on regular water or water+lime/lemon juice is flavored sparkling water. When I think to buy them (about twice a month) I drink maybe 12oz(355ml) to a liter to every 2-3 glasses of water (I drink a lot of water in the Florida summer). They squash my soda fix (I didn't really care for HFCS sodas anyway, if I'm gonna have a soda it's going to have cane sugar in it).
My mainstays are the Pellegrino Grapefruit sparkling water, and the LaCroix sparkling water in cans (the coconut or lime flavors are my most common pickups).
Ingredients on either product both say "Sparkling water, natural flavor" and nothing more. Being my normal skeptical self, I'm at odds with the ambiguous "natural flavor" ingredient, and honestly, the stuff tastes really good (drinking the coconut flavor currently). Neither product has any macronutrient value, with the exception of a percent or so of sodium in the Pellegrino. But I'm always wary - and want to make sure I'm not setting myself up for some sort of fail down the road. Additional concerns might be if there was any BPA content in the canned product (I don't buy Pellegrino in plastic, I choose the glass bottles).
I know purists might say "pssh... just drink water" but sometimes you (read: I) need a little something more.
What say you, PH? Safe or scary?
asked byJoshua_1 (21430)
Get FREE instant access to our Paleo For Beginners Guide & 15 FREE Recipes!
on June 04, 2012
at 03:56 PM
Lets examine the ingredients:
- Water: Mostly safe
- Sparkling: You're exhaling it right now, mostly safe
- Natural Flavor: Considering how little is needed to actually flavor something, mostly safe
Safe unless you're drowning in it.
I adore grapefruit juice. I buy it and drink it when I've got a hankering. Could I eat whole grapefruits instead? Sure, but I only do that if I want a grapefruit. Is it safe? Mercaptans can reduce glutathione peroxidase activity and they tell you not to drink it if you're taking certain meds. I'm not on those meds and I don't care, it brings a smile to my face and I feel good when I have it. I think the stress of worrying about it is far worse than the product. There is something to be said about enjoying something and being happy.
on June 05, 2012
at 01:18 AM
Regardless of safety, I find home made to be much tastier and more satisfying.
I get high mineral sparkling water and add one of the following:
Lemon, Grapefruit, or Orange Zest or Slices
Strawberry, Watermelon, or Raspberry Puree
or if you are feeling slightly naughty a spoonful of liqueur like pear brandy, Disaronno, or Sambuca
on June 04, 2012
at 06:15 PM
Dude, La Croix is a "safe beverage" in my book. Have never tried the coconut, but really enjoy the lemon with or without vodka and the grapefruit is good stuff too. I wouldn't worry your head over it.
And Pellegrino is sparkling mineral water. I drink that or Perrier almost everyday.
on June 04, 2012
at 04:32 PM
safe, hopefully! Sparkling water/seltzer/club soda... if you're really worried, get yourself a seltzer maker, and your water can get bubbly too. Then get your own citrus. :)
on March 27, 2017
at 07:49 PM
The natural flavor is worrying. It is possible to add, for example, yeast extract or some sort of derivative therein as a "natural flavor" to food. Why would somene do that? Because yeast is VERY high in naturally occuring MSG. And that is indeed legal, despite what is said above. Let me share a story with you.
I bought some vegan butter (Earth Balance) once because i had a coupon making it free. The entire tub was gone in 3-4 days. I inhaled it on buttered toast and bagels and when I ran out of those, toasted hot dog buns. Seriously. And I went back to the store for seconds. Some time through the second tub it occurred to me how strange it was how much "butter" I was eating and how I seemed to be wanting even more and more of it the more I ate. So I looked at the ingredients. Everything looked normal and food-like except for the last ingredient "natural flavors."
I had heard in the past that this can hide naturally derived MSG-laden "flavorings" and my empty bread pantry seemed to back that up.
More recently I bought some truvia which has ingredients "Erythritol, Stevia extract, natural flavoring." Now, right off the bat your alarms should be going off because a sweetener is sweet, it isn't *anything* flavored. So why is it there? Well I attempted to use it to sweeten some unsweetened, flavored sparkling water. Same thing happened as with the butter, except a little slower which I guess can be attributed to the lower concentration. I vacuumed up those sodas and by the end of the case I was drinking 3 a day instead of the planned 1 with my one-meal-a-day. And I was actually starting to calculate and countdown the hours until it would be socially acceptable for me to have another.
Natural flavors can and routinely DOES contain appetite stimulant. This is a fact. I'd avoid anything that contains it if possible because who knows what these chemicals, even though they are extracted from natural things, are doing to our bodies and minds. And since they are only meant to make us overeat and crave, where is the pro to that uncertainty?
on November 04, 2014
at 12:44 AM
I just discovered that a bunch of you guys' answers have been plagiarized on some health blog. Verbatim. I'll try and post a link
on June 07, 2013
at 06:41 PM
I did some research and the most likely candidate for the flavoring is g-nonalactone, the aromatic compound responsible for coconut scent. This molecule is naturally found in coconuts; for LaCroix's purposes, I'm sure it's synthesized in the lab. So, it's a natural thing, just manufactured artificially. For more info, I'd say to look up health info on g-nonalactone.
on May 09, 2013
at 09:57 PM
From their web site
What ingredients make up the 'Natural Flavors' in the LaCroix flavors?
The flavors are derived from the natural essence oils extracted from the fruits used in each of our LaCroix flavors. There are no sugars or artificial ingredients contained in, nor added to, these extracted flavors.
I was looking it up because I feel a little off after drinking any of their flavors. Itis also causing me not to sleep. Very interesting.
on December 08, 2012
at 09:06 PM
I'm definitely a skeptic... but I still drink La Croix.
The definition of natural flavor under the Code of Federal Regulations is: “the essential oil, oleoresin, essence or extractive, protein hydrolysate, distillate, or any product of roasting, heating or enzymolysis, which contains the flavoring constituents derived from a spice, fruit or fruit juice, vegetable or vegetable juice, edible yeast, herb, bark, bud, root, leaf or similar plant material, meat, seafood, poultry, eggs, dairy products, or fermentation products thereof, whose significant function in food is flavoring rather than nutritional” (21CFR101.22).
on June 04, 2012
at 06:04 PM
I find the flavors in La Croix taste too artificially to me. A squirt of real lemon or lime juice works great without the mystery ingredients. Real coconut water should be nice also.
on June 04, 2012
at 05:29 PM
Speaking of the Pellegrino, I consider them "not safe." At least the ones I have seen (an internet search on grapefruit, plus the lemon, orange, and blood orange that I sell at work), they have either added sugar, or the juice is "from concentrate," in which case it is almost pure fructose. Check the carb count on the bottle. The LaCroix is listed as zero everything.
If you want sparkling water, you can always make your own. Take seltzer water and add fruit to it.
on June 04, 2012
at 04:02 PM
I like La Croix in the glass bottles. The cans seem to have a tinny taste to them IMO. Either lemon or lime are my favorites. Their web site says that there is nothing artificial in it so I guess it must be ok.
I think it quenches my thirst better than plain water...the bubbles, I guess. Agree with you, don't like the sweetened stuff and it always seemed to make me thirstier anyway. (BTW, never figured out if it's pronounced 'la cwah' or 'la croy'.)
on August 29, 2012
at 02:34 PM
I just finished a 30 day clean paleo challenge - 100% strict. i just tried the la croix water after the 30 days - i am really in-tune with my body right now and i can tell this stuff did more negative than positive. my throat feels dry, and i want more water... i'll stick to real mineral water for sure... and add a squeeze from a lime if i want flavor.
Over All: La Croix - PALEO FAIL.