3

votes

Is this article about Betaine HCL valid ?

Answered on August 19, 2014
Created October 05, 2012 at 4:27 PM

I am taking Betaine HCL for a week now, I take 3-4 capsules per meal and it has definitely helped my digestion. My question is about this article:

http://metabolichealing.com/key-integrated-functions-of-your-body/gut/the-hcl-challenge-why-the-conventional-test-is-dead-wrong/

Is there any merit to it? I am following GAPS do damaging my gut more than I am helping it wouldn't be good.

Thanks for any answers

194d8e8140425057fe06202e1e5822a7

(3979)

on October 06, 2012
at 04:40 AM

My question is will Betaine HCl supplementation make the body produce less of it on its own?

6120c989fd5b69f42a0834b69b87955b

(24553)

on October 06, 2012
at 03:52 AM

The way it was described to me was that when you get to point where you feel a slight warmth, like having had a cup of black coffee on an empty stomach up near the esophagus, that is likely one pill too many, and one pill less would be the correct dosage.

34997c76c8ce232f28942f233e180f18

(608)

on October 05, 2012
at 06:32 PM

This answer makes a lot of sense to me, thanks! I feel without the HCL I wouldn't be moving in the right direction, so this kind of reassures me :)

34997c76c8ce232f28942f233e180f18

(608)

on October 05, 2012
at 06:32 PM

Can you elaborate on the warmth feeling? I kind of cut back on the HCL after I got what you described. I'm not getting any burning in the stomach just somewhat near the esophagus. Not sure what I should do :S Thanks for the answer!

68294383ced9a0eafc16133aa80d1905

(5795)

on October 05, 2012
at 06:28 PM

Unfortunately, I think many may misconstrue this as a reason to NOT use HCL. That's a big mistake. It has its place, and like the article points out, the body can handle A LOT of it. Hence, supplementation isn't harmful, as long as there isn't damage already present. I know personally, when I'm trying to gain mass and need to eat a lot of food, I tend to use a decent amount of HCL because I still prefer a confined feeding window, which means a lot of intake at once. This is very difficult to maintain comfortability without some assistance. It would be a shame if this led to less HCL use

Frontpage book

Get FREE instant access to our Paleo For Beginners Guide & 15 FREE Recipes!

2 Answers

1
68294383ced9a0eafc16133aa80d1905

(5795)

on October 05, 2012
at 06:07 PM

I think it makes some sense, but I also think they are missing the whole point. A lot of this is based on assumption, but here goes.

  1. The reason many people supplement with HCL or undertake the recommended dosing of supplemental Betane HCL is because a digestive issue has already been identified.

  2. If a digestive issue is identified, this person also has to realize what is causing it. If that isn't done, and a shift in the TYPES OF FOOD being ingested is neglected, it's not going to matter anyway whether one supplements with HCL or not. The gut won't be healed.

  3. If using the HCL is combined with an improvement in food intake, the gut is going to slowly heal. Will it heal as fast as someone doing GAPS and eliminating everything problematic 100%? No. Will it slowly improve over time? Yes.

So while there may be some flaws in the recommendations by some on how to test your natural levels of HCL, using the HCL, which will improve digestion, should slowly contribute to gut healing. The means to the end will be different, but the ultimate goal is to heal the gut and not need to supplement. By telling people NOT to try the HCL may actually cause people to never get to the end they are trying to get to.

34997c76c8ce232f28942f233e180f18

(608)

on October 05, 2012
at 06:32 PM

This answer makes a lot of sense to me, thanks! I feel without the HCL I wouldn't be moving in the right direction, so this kind of reassures me :)

0
6120c989fd5b69f42a0834b69b87955b

(24553)

on October 05, 2012
at 06:22 PM

I'm a big fan of Betaine HCL, and benefited greatly from it, and I also agree with the article. When I was under the care of a holistic nutritionist, she recommended taking it, but not without spending 1-2 months beforehand healing the mucosal lining of my gut, for which she suggested daily aloe juice (although I suspect any demulcent herb, and/or daily broth consumption would do the same).

I also wonder if there might be a misunderstanding between the feeling of warmth higher up near the esophagus that I was supposed to aim for, and burning, burning, down in the stomach like one would experience from an ulcer that isn't being distinguished clearly enough in the article and perhaps also when the Betaine HCL trials are being recommended.

If you feel like it is helping your digestion, and following a GAPS protocol simultaneously, I'd say keep at it, you are on the road to healing.

6120c989fd5b69f42a0834b69b87955b

(24553)

on October 06, 2012
at 03:52 AM

The way it was described to me was that when you get to point where you feel a slight warmth, like having had a cup of black coffee on an empty stomach up near the esophagus, that is likely one pill too many, and one pill less would be the correct dosage.

34997c76c8ce232f28942f233e180f18

(608)

on October 05, 2012
at 06:32 PM

Can you elaborate on the warmth feeling? I kind of cut back on the HCL after I got what you described. I'm not getting any burning in the stomach just somewhat near the esophagus. Not sure what I should do :S Thanks for the answer!

Answer Question


Get FREE instant access to our
Paleo For Beginners Guide & 15 FREE Recipes!