Hi I suffer from Hidradenitis Suppurativa and currently live gluten free. I came across this the other day:
There is a bit about nightshades in it. Since I have been eating Gluten Free I have been having a lot of omelettes for breakfast including a lot of bell peppers which seems to have induced an outbreak of facial acne. I also eat a lot of tomato based and chilli pepper based food and now wondering what the hell to eat?
I also suffer from IBS but don't get tummy ache when I eat a gluten free diet apart I do seem to be able able to cheat with bread with no ill effect and dairy doesn't seem to bother me, but I had a jacket potato with tuna the other day and I immediately felt poorly and my stomach balooned, I am now wondering whether it's not gluten at all and if it is nightshades I have a problem with? Can anyone help?
asked byMichelle_17 (10)
Get FREE instant access to our Paleo For Beginners Guide & 15 FREE Recipes!
on August 06, 2013
at 01:30 AM
I have had manifestations of HS for more than 20 years and I also stumbled upon Primal Girl's post about nightshades. I have been working on staying Paleo since last September when I was diagnosed with diabetes and have since dropped 30 pounds. I quit smoking in October.
I have continuous flares and infection under my arms. I take turmeric to reduce inflammation but it seems to be less and less effective - hopefully only due to the huge amount of tomatoes and peppers I have been consuming.
I have eaten hot peppers and tomatoes all my life - In a past life, I must have been Mexican because Mexican food and I are like this :::twines fingers together:::. I didn't eat eggs too much because they really irritated my stomach, caused me to bloat terribly.
Last November I realized, quite suddenly, that I had a gallbladder problem. I went to my doctor and told her that I needed my gallbladder removed, we did some tests and then had it removed. After it was removed, I was able to eat eggs without any "apparent" problem.
Every morning after my surgery, I ate two scrambled eggs with salsa. For lunch, I ate 6 ounces of chicken and a handful of frozen vegetables, then for supper, I had a gigantic salad with 6 ounces of chicken, tomatoes, jalapeno slices and my guilty pleasure - ranch dressing.
On August 1st 2013, I cut out all tomatoes, peppers and eggs (because I read that they can cause irritation) and then started experimenting with dabbing milk of magnesia on my spots and letting it dry. So far, the milk of magnesia treatments are inconclusive - my underarms really hurt in spot-central locations, but the spots seem to be draining , which causes my underarms to chafe.
This past Sunday morning, we went to Golden Corral for breakfast, like we always do - where I normally would get scrambled eggs with jalapenos, bell peppers, mushrooms and onions or a spinach omelet with mushrooms, jalapenos, bell peppers, onions and a few pieces of bacon.
Just to see what would happen with my underarms (even though they weren't healed up but they weren't terribly painful ... ) I went and got a big clump of cheese enchiladas with spicy red sauce and ate every bit of it. And loved it!!!
Well, my underarms flared up again, so I think that I may be on to something with cutting out nightshades. Now all I have to do is pretend I don't like them and don't miss them...
on April 11, 2012
at 01:35 PM
I'll quote Robb Wolf on this: try it for 30 days and see what happens? The worst case is that you miss out on some tasty food for a month, the best case is that you heal up.
on January 23, 2013
at 06:25 PM
I have HS and half successfully used Gluten Free and Paleo to help my HS greatly. I have a group of 165 people with the same goal. All are welcome to join. It is a private group so you have to ask to join. The HS Diet Connection. http://www.facebook.com/groups/hsandglutenfree/?bookmark_t=group
on August 08, 2012
at 05:56 PM
Someone with HS claims to heal by staying away from nightshades:
I too have HS, but don't have anything conclusive about nightshades. I'll start paying more attention to it.
on April 11, 2012
at 02:13 PM
Like almost any exclusion diet, once you get going with it you are fine. I started the AI protocol last month and found it actually rather easy and felt great doing it for the two weeks I was able to actually do it. While traveling extensively the past few weeks, I had to reintroduce eggs because my options were so limited (and I also ate all sorts of crap, feel terrible, and am gleefully getting back into a very strict paleo routine).
I thought it would be hell to give up my full fat yogurt, but now I don't even think about it. I say give it a try for about two weeks. If it seems too daunting, just give up one thing at a time and see how you fare. My guess, based exclusively on my own experience, is that the nightshades or the egg whites are the culprit of your acne.
on April 11, 2012
at 01:52 PM
I had this condition for a few months and was able to trace it back to salicylates -both in topical personal care producst, household and environmental products, and in food. I have to eat a paleo very low salicylate diet. Haven't had a problem since salicylates were eliminated and avoided
on April 11, 2012
at 12:36 PM
Nightshades contain high levels of alkaloids. This can be problematic for some people but not everyone. The nightshade family is very diverse but includes potatoes, tomatoes, sweet and hot peppers, eggplant, tomatillos, tamarios, pepinos, pimentos,and paprika. In addition, some eggplants in particular contain some nicotine in their skin. I would recommend a try it and see approach with each one.