So, I've been eating primal for about a year and a half. I'm a 21 year old petite female, who has always had a naturally athletic/muscular build. I started paleo in an effort to be healthier, without intent to modify my weight or body composition, but over the past year or so I've noticed that I have inadvertently gained more muscle, but not had any significant fat loss, and the result is that I feel very bulky for my stature. The question is, is there any way I can modify my diet or training to lean out my muscles? I eat fairly low carb and high fat, because it is a ratio at which I enjoy the best mood (I feel very anxious with higher levels of carbohydrates). I sprint, and lift weights, and walk everywhere throughout the week. Have any other women had a similar experience? I feel like my body is looking more masculine (not stronger) than I would like. Could it be hormonal imbalance? Or too much protein? Or just being completely silly? Thanks!
asked byReina (16)
Get FREE instant access to our Paleo For Beginners Guide & 15 FREE Recipes!
on April 11, 2013
at 02:35 AM
I think this could be attributed to the fact that you are eating higher protein and lifting weights - I am definitely NOT SAY to cut out either, but I do think that maybe focusing on pilates and performing more cardiovascular exercise will help you feel less bulky. This at least has worked for me.
on March 28, 2013
at 01:06 AM
I would suggest keeping protein high and dropping the fat A LITTLE BIT. When I first started paleo, I didn't yet know how it worked. I ate pretty low carb, high protein, and pretty low fat. Sure, I lost a ton of weight, but I became skinny fat! I lost a lot of muscle on my upper body, which made my hips look bigger--UGH!!! I found that I lose some fat without losing all that muscle by:
- eating carbs smartly. I do not eat high carb. I eat around 100g per day on training days. I eat them after my workouts, kind of like the carb backloading strategy
- don't go too high fat or you won't burn your own. this does not mean go low-fat, it just means don't go crazy adding butter and oil to everything
- this is always a sore subject, but you may have to be mindful of calories. I am also a short girl, and if I eat way more calories than I need, it shows
on May 30, 2013
at 12:07 PM
Sounds like you just need to lose body fat, and then you'll feel less bulky.
After all, it's virtually impossible to get "bulky' naturally from just being muscular. 1 lb of muscle is more dense than 1lb of fat. That is, the more muscles you have and the less body fat you have, you will end up occupying less space than someone of the same weight but who carries less muscle mass than you have.
M*Oral of the story- MUSCLE IS NOT WHATS MAKING YOU BULKY- FAT IS. Drop the fat.*
You could try carb cycling;
High carb days eat approximately 1.4g protein/lb bodyweight. 1.4g carbs/lb bodyweight, and 0.3g fat/lb bodyweight.
Low carb days eat approximately 1.2g protein/lb, 0.6g/carbs, and 0.5g fats/lb bodyweight.
That should have the fat off you in no time (provided you're still lifting weights) and you'll appear much less "bulky." Like a ballerina with clothes but a sculpture without.
on April 11, 2013
at 02:41 AM
You are not alone! I am in a very similar situation. 21, female, muscular but too "bulky" for my liking.
Currently my plan is to "cut" as bodybuilders call it. I like my muscle and i'm an athlete but but extra chub has got to go. (I want my abs back!) I'm watching calories to a certain extent and cycling my calories/carbs too (leangains kinda style). I'm hoping that this will help. I'm cutting back on fruit (3-4 servings per week) and incorporating some long distance runs. (working my way up to 10miles, never running more than 3-4 days of the week.
I've been kinda watching what fitness models do to maintain muscle, but get extremely cut. It seems a tad drastic but i'm modifying a plan to hopefully work for me.
I'm not dropping my protein, because I don't think losing muscle is the answer. Hormones also play a role too, as far as what you can control, make sure you get enough sleep. Doing some fasted cardio might help? Best of luck!
on April 11, 2013
at 02:11 AM
Try bodyweight exercises or dance (ballet/jazz/african/modern, etc) instead of lifting.